Umschuldung in Germany: compare settlement and total cost
Umschuldung means replacing existing borrowing with a new agreement. A German overdraft, or Dispokredit, needs particular care because its balance can be drawn again and may have no fixed end date. First establish a realistic repayment path, then compare it with the new loan’s complete schedule. A high rate or several accounts alone does not establish that you should consolidate.
Credizen analysis
1. Obtain an Ablösebetrag for a specific date
BGB § 500 addresses early repayment; § 501 provides for reduction of credit costs relating to the remaining contractual period when repayment is made under that provision. Property-related consumer loans have different conditions from ordinary consumer instalment loans.
Ask each provider for a dated settlement amount, its validity, the account to pay and any instalment due before the transfer. For a Ratenkredit, obtain the remaining schedule and last payment. Do not compare the original borrowed amount with a new settlement figure or add already-paid interest to future costs.
For a Dispo, record today’s used balance, rate basis, any account costs and a feasible clearing plan with no further drawing. If the old path is “leave it outstanding indefinitely”, it has no meaningful fixed total to rank against a two-year loan. Make the intended time horizon explicit.
2. Check Vorfälligkeitsentschädigung rather than guessing
BGB § 502 sets conditions and exclusions for early-repayment compensation. For general consumer loans it limits that charge to 1% of the amount repaid early, or 0.5% where the remaining interval does not exceed one year, and also limits it by the interest otherwise payable in that period.
These are limits for the stated legal category, not a fee automatically owed on every balance. Ask whether a charge applies, how it was calculated and where it appears in the settlement figure. Do not apply those percentages to a mortgage without checking the distinct rules.
For a purely mathematical ceiling illustration, 1% of €7,000 is €70 and 0.5% is €35. That calculation does not determine which limit applies to your contract or whether any compensation is due. Keep the actual provider’s dated explanation with the comparison.
3. Put the same debts on a complete worksheet
Fictional example, not bank quotations: an instalment account needs €7,000 to settle and otherwise has twenty remaining payments of €390. An overdraft needs €3,000 to clear and has an agreed illustrative clearing path of four payments of €800 with no redraw. Assume both paths already include all future charges and that the settlement figures include any applicable settlement costs.
The same debts require €10,000 to settle. Continuing costs 20 × €390 + 4 × €800 = €11,000. For the first four months the combined payment is €1,190; after that only €390 remains for sixteen months. This declining commitment matters when comparing a new fixed monthly amount.
Suppose a replacement settles exactly €10,000, requires 24 payments of €465 and has €100 paid separately at the start, with no other charges. Total future payments are 24 × €465 + €100 = €11,260, which is €260 more. The initial monthly reduction is €725, but repayment continues four months beyond the original instalment account. No interest rate or market saving is inferred from this fictional schedule.
4. Compare Effektivzins, insurance and cleared limits
PAngV § 16 requires an effective annual rate based on the relevant total costs. It distinguishes obligatory known costs from specified exclusions, including certain voluntary extras and default-related costs.
Record the personal offer’s Effektivzins and Sollzins separately, together with net proceeds, payment dates, total amount and any Restschuldversicherung. Do not calculate a new schedule from a marketing “from” rate or treat the effective rate as the contractual nominal monthly rate. Include a financed premium once, in the place the agreement puts it.
Decide what happens to an overdraft limit or revolving account after settlement. Obtain confirmation of the old balance and agree any deliberate limit reduction or closure. Clearing a balance does not prevent you from drawing it again; new spending can leave both the consolidation loan and fresh overdraft debt.
5. Use a budget shortfall as a reason to seek help
Test the new payment against housing, food, transport, dependants and all remaining debts, including a weaker-income month. If it only works with overtime or further borrowing, ask current creditors about a written arrangement and consider independent Schuldnerberatung before signing another loan. Check who provides the service, its costs and the applicable local contact.
Keep the current schedules, settlement letters, new offer and written answers. Ask which credit inquiry a quote or application triggers. Consolidation is not a promise of a higher credit score, automatic acceptance or a permanent solution to spending more than the household receives.
Questions before deciding
Should I consolidate immediately because my overdraft rate is high?
Establish a no-redraw clearing path and compare it with the complete replacement cost, term and budget. A high rate alone does not show that the new agreement saves money or is affordable.
Is an early-repayment charge always 1%?
No. The legal category, fixed-rate conditions, remaining period, applicable exclusions and the interest otherwise due matter. Obtain the actual settlement calculation rather than treating a percentage limit as a compulsory fee.