Debt consolidation in South Africa: compare the full cost
A consolidation loan replaces existing debts with a new credit agreement. The useful comparison is the same debts, on the same settlement date, with every repayment and fee included. This guide shows a clearly fictional worksheet that separates monthly breathing room from total savings; it makes no claim about a lender’s current rate, speed or approval.
Credizen analysis
1. Decide whether the problem is cost, dates or an unaffordable budget
The NCR brochure distinguishes consolidation, which combines debts into a new loan, from debt counselling. They are not interchangeable services.
List the accounts you want to settle and the reason for doing so. Fewer due dates may solve an organisation problem, but a continuing gap between essentials, income and repayments may need a different response. Do not start with a deadline such as “money in one hour” and then choose whichever lender replies first.
Record your actual take-home income, essential household costs and all debt payments. Include expenses that occur less often than monthly. If a new instalment requires uncertain overtime or another loan to cover food or rent, reconsider the amount and plan before applying.
2. Put two existing debts on one dated worksheet
Fictional household illustration, not customer records or lender quotations: Account A has a settlement figure of R12,000 and ten remaining payments of R1,400. Account B has a settlement figure of R8,000 and eight remaining payments of R1,150. Assume these fixed schedules already include all remaining account charges and have no balloon payments or further spending.
The same two debts require R12,000 + R8,000 = R20,000 to settle on the chosen date. Continuing the illustrative schedules instead means 10 × R1,400 + 8 × R1,150 = R23,200 in future payments. Their combined payment is R2,550 while both remain active; it falls once Account B is repaid, so do not treat R2,550 as a permanent monthly cost.
3. Add the complete new-loan cost before calling it a saving
Continue the same fictional worksheet: suppose a replacement loan settles exactly R20,000, requires eighteen monthly payments of R1,300 and has one R300 charge paid separately upfront. Assume no extra cash is advanced and no other charges apply in this illustration. These invented amounts demonstrate arithmetic; they are not a market offer or a permitted-fee limit.
Total future outlay after switching is 18 × R1,300 + R300 = R23,700. Compared with R23,200 under the two existing schedules, switching costs R500 more. The initial combined payment falls by R2,550 − R1,300 = R1,250, but the upfront charge and longer repayment period remain. Lower instalments and lower total cost are different outcomes.
For real documents, replace every illustrative amount with the dated settlement figures, complete new payment schedule and confirmed charges. If a fee is financed and already included in the instalment total, do not add it again. If a charge, insurance premium or final payment is unknown, the comparison is incomplete; an unknown amount is not zero.
4. Confirm settlement and stop old balances rebuilding
Ask who pays each old account, the transfer date and how you will receive confirmation. Check the settlement quote’s validity and any payment still due before settlement. Keep paying according to your applicable agreement unless a valid change is confirmed; a pending application is not a payment holiday.
After transfer, obtain confirmation of the old account’s balance and status. Decide separately whether a revolving limit should be reduced or closed and request written confirmation. If you borrow again on cleared accounts while repaying the new loan, you have created an additional obligation rather than simply combined the original debts.
5. Compare flexibility, insurance and security as separate decisions
The NFO’s credit tips tell readers to consider total repayment as well as instalments and warn that a longer term can increase the total paid.
Request the interest-rate type, repayment dates, all service and initiation charges, insurance cost, any security and the terms for extra or early payments. Ask what happens if income drops or a payment date needs changing. A provider’s name or a general marketing benefit does not answer those questions for your agreement.
If the new arrangement uses a vehicle or home as security for previously unsecured borrowing, understand the consequences with appropriate assistance. Do not treat a smaller repayment as compensation for an asset risk you have not assessed.
6. Ask about a written arrangement before taking more credit
The NFO advises contacting the credit provider when instalments become difficult and keeping a copy of a new or revised agreement in writing.
Ask current providers whether dates, instalments or terms can be adjusted and what that would cost overall. Compare the response with a new loan using the same starting balances and time period. If you need a formal assessment for debt counselling, use an NCR-registered counsellor and the separate process guide; do not equate that process with a consolidation approval.
7. Take these questions to the provider
Which debts will be settled, and on which date? How much is paid to each creditor, and is any cash paid to me? What will I pay in total, including charges outside the instalment? Which amounts change if the rate changes? Who confirms the old accounts are settled? What happens to insurance and unused limits?
Ask for answers and the full schedule before signing. This is a reader’s checklist, not a recommendation by a named expert and not a reason to send simultaneous applications without understanding the checks and terms.
8. Resolve errors before relying on the comparison
The NFO Credit Division says it considers complaints within its scope about participating credit providers after the consumer has first complained directly to the provider.
Keep the settlement quote, agreement, payment proof, account statements and complaint reference. An unexplained charge or missing settlement confirmation needs a written response. This guide does not establish a current tariff, legal entitlement to a refund, a provider’s licence status or your personal approval.
Questions about consolidation costs
Does a smaller consolidated instalment prove I save money?
No. In the fictional worksheet, the initial payment falls but the total rises by R500. Repeat the comparison with your actual schedules, all fees and the same debts before drawing a conclusion.
Is debt consolidation the same as debt counselling?
No. Consolidation involves a new loan to settle existing debts. Debt counselling is a separate process with its own assessment, restrictions and documentation. Obtain case-specific advice rather than choosing by a marketing label.
Existing lender and education references
- Home
- Blog
- Financial Education
- budgeting guide
- wonga — provider reference
- lime — provider reference
- blue finance — provider reference
- capitec — provider reference
- Application information — verify terms before proceeding
- Credit history: related guide
- Interest and total credit cost: related guide
- Debt review: related guide
- View All Articles
- african bank — provider reference
- lime24 — provider reference
- Methodology
- Responsible borrowing
- Contact and corrections
- Editorial policy
- Legal